
1. What type of miniatures are we talking about?
Is it just the casual D&D game, needing some orcs or undead minis that the party is about to encounter? Is it basic 40k troops (guardsmen, marines, etc.)? Or are we talking high detail painting miniatures for Golden Demon Awards or maybe really small Epic armies? Are they going to be looked at just table top level, or under the microscope?
2. What else are you looking to print?
Maybe the occasional scenic base or special terrain piece or are you looking for 6X4 board of buildings or complete dungeon scape? Maybe icon holders or card deck dividers or storage solutions? Could the 3d printer be commandeered by someone else in the house for other nefarious things (like dollhouses)?
3. How much effort are you really wanting to put into it?
This really is a serious question. Is this a casual hobby? Are you looking at production/resell? I was really gung-ho on resin until I looked at the production of cleaning and curing not to mention smell and mess to begin with.
The above list on the previous post is good, but if you did a search on a per month basis, it changes pretty frequently. There are units to stay away from, but the mainstream production manufactures (Phrozen, Eryone, AnyCubic, Ender 3, Elegoo) all have their pluses and minuses, and people that advocate for each. For me, I answered the 3 questions this way.
1. Simple 40k troops and D&D minis. I don't paint Golden Demon standards so what I am looking for is a clean model without the lines. Extrusion printers have come a LONG way since I first saw them and gone are the days of the ribbed look when printing. Depending on settings, can have a very smooth surface.
2. A lot of terrain is in my future. I figure I am going to spend the money on GW minis, I have to save the money on terrain pieces. As they don't have to be absolute flawless, resin is just to expensive to cast multiple boards worth of terrain. I am also getting back into D&D, and I've seen some awesome dungeons done on Ender machines. The other table top games I play have a ton of extra printable add-ons for storage, game aids, and extras that I have always wanted to create. I see a lot of do-hick-ees and thing-a-ma-bobs in my future.
3. This ended up being my deciding factor. Right now, out of the gate, this is just an intro into the hobby for me. I want to see how it goes and really how interested I am in continuing. I know myself in that I don't want something that has a high production cost (time, effort, cleaning, curing, extra parts) to get started as I might get frustrated early and then it just sits. Also, I live in a smaller condo, so some of the smells, noise, cleaning solutions and overall space is a bit higher then I want to begin with.
Overall, I am looking at extrusion method for first purchase (which? I don't know, that is next step), and down the way might invest in resin. With the new 4k print screens just coming online for manufactures this year, maybe next Christmas after prices come down a bit.
Good luck and post what you decide on. As I am new to this board, I'm sure to be here a bit and look forward to seeing things built for inspiration.